Brownies space a mix of cake and also cookies and also are among the most preferred desserts that the entirety family deserve to enjoy. However, they are often taken into consideration to be fattening and somewhat unhealthy as result of the oil content. If you room worried about the harmful impacts of vegetables oil in brownies, or you’re simply trying to reduced down ~ above fat, or perhaps you don’t have it in your kitchen, there room a many substitutes because that oil in brownies mix the you may uncover useful.

You are watching: Can i substitute oil for butter in brownie mix

No issue what form of brownies you’re making, whether it’s coco or any other flavor, the primary ingredients room brownie mix, egg, and also oil. The lack of among these ingredients will make it challenging or maybe impossible to do brownies. If the absent ingredient is oil, several various other ingredients deserve to substitute oil in the brownies mix.

Brownies Nutrition Facts:


Baking with Oil

We must know the role of oil in make brownies before we try to substitute it because that something else, together this ensures we room replacing it correctly. The biggest function oil dram in brownies (and any kind of other dessert) is maintaining them moist by slowing down gluten formation to save them tender and fluffy in texture. Baking v oil likewise helps in binding all other ingredients together. So once substituting oil, you have to pay fist to exactly how your alternating ingredients deserve to perform these 2 tasks.

Benefits the Baking without Oil

Staying slim and also eating properly is about getting as numerous nutrients together you have the right to in fewer calories than the average person. Oil are typically healthy resources of fat, but since some of lock contain a high amount of polyunsaturated omega-6 fat (like canola oil, sunflower oil, sesame oil, and rice bran oil), they may negatively affect your health. Hydrogenated oils space often uncovered in handle foods and takeaway. They are an extremely unhealthy together they contain infectious diseases world fashion fats, which contributes to obesity, high blood pressure, love disease, stroke, and type 2 diabetes. Castle can additionally cause your good cholesterol come reduce and also increase your poor cholesterol.

Substitute because that oil in brownies mix

There are countless substitutes because that oil, some much more healthy 보다 others. When selecting a substitute for oil in brownies mix, our main factor to consider should be the flavor; this is due to the fact that oil has a very mild taste, and also you wouldn’t want the replacement provided to be also overpowering because that the recipe.



Applesauce is a low-fat substitute for vegetable oil and is a purée made out of apples. It gives the moisture necessary for the basic mixing the the cooking recipes without the undesirable fat and also calories. Applesauce does not change your brownies’ taste, so as soon as baking, that is recommended that you take it the very same amount the applesauce as the variety of vegetables to preserve the flavor and also textures of her brownies. Although utilizing applesauce may an outcome in your brownies gift drier than normal, it have the right to be prevent by including a tiny extra liquid contents to your batter and also reducing the roasted time by a pair of minutes (around 10 minutes).

Mashed Banana


Mashed ripe bananas space a good substitute for oil when making brownies. Using mashed ripe banana as a substitute for oil in brownies keeps castle soft and also moist. Simply pick a an extremely ripe banana and mash it to a soft purée and substitute it for the mix’s oil. If the mix requires 1/2 cup of oil, you need to use 1/2 cup of banana instead. Utilizing mashed bananas in make brownies may result in them gift drier than usual, and also like with other substitutes, including extra water and reducing the bake time can fix this.

Melted Butter


Butter is no the healthiest choice as a substitute for oil in baking brownies because of that high-fat content. Utilizing butter together a substitute provides a slightly creamier taste that vegetable oil cannot give. To melt the butter, you have the right to either put the butter in a microwaveable safe bowl and also heat in the microwave increments the fifteen secs until it has melted or put it in a pan on the stove and melt it that way. When baking, use the same quantity of butter together the amount of vegetable oil required in the recipe however make sure you roasted the brownies at the very least two minutes longer than normal to preserve the very same flavor and also texture.

Yogurt and also Buttermilk


Yogurt and buttermilk are dairy-based substitutes because that oil in brownie recipes. Using level yogurt is a far better choice because that baking 보다 flavored yogurt. If you’re making a recipe that requires 1/2 cup of oil, you must use a 1/4 cup of plain yogurt or buttermilk. It is necessary to cut back on baking time (at the very least 10 minutes) or add a small water to protect against your brownies indigenous being too dry.

Read More: Ravioli through Garlic Basil Oil Recipe



Cornstarch likewise works as an oil substitute because that baking brownies. Mix 4 tablespoons that cornstarch v a tiny water and heat until you obtain your wanted consistency. It need to be offered in the cooking recipes as soon as that cools. As soon as using cornstarch together a substitute for oil in brownies, make sure you use the same amount as you would v oil.

See more: What Did Bastian Name The Empress In The Neverending Story "

Fruit Purée


Fruit purée can be supplied as an oil instead of in her brownie recipes, despite it’ll reason your brownie to have actually a cakey texture. Stop using fruit with strong flavors together it may influence the brownies’ taste; instead, walk for soft flavors favor a prune, avocado, and also pumpkin.



Oil shortening is a an easy solid vegetable oil that has actually gone v hydrogenation (the process of turning liquid oil right into a semi-solid form). That would help if girlfriend heated the shortening prior to mixing with various other ingredients as it will mix easier this way. Once using shortening, you can use the same amount as you would with oil. That is commonly flavorless, making the a an excellent substitute because that oil when you’re baking brownies. However, they can contain infectious diseases worldwide fat, i m sorry is unhealthy because that the body together it can increase your risk of love attack and also stroke.