This video clip presents an introduction of the Civil battle comparing the North and the South. The North had actually 22 states and 22 million people. The South had actually only 11 states and also 9 million people. The North had actually most of the U.S. Provides of and accessibility to coal, iron, and copper. It also had 92% the the country’s industry. The North had actually twice as countless railroads and also a vastly larger navy. At the beginning of the war, the South had actually no standing military or navy and also the troops to be purely voluntary, despite they at some point instituted a draft. The North had actually a vast advantage in convoy numbers. The southern had advantages as well. Several of the advantages included: They were fighting ~ above their very own soil with inner lines that defense and also knowledge that the terrain. The Southern armed forces officers had much more experience and capability than their northern counterparts. The southern was fighting to maintain their lives and also property, which is much more tangible than fighting for an ideal (preservation that the union, collection men free). Finally, the south was may be to critical as long as they did due to the fact that they battled a primarily defensive war.
You are watching: Civil war north vs south advantages
Hi, and welcome to this testimonial of the American polite War! In this video, we’re walking to specifically be talking about the two opposing sides, the North and the South. First, we’ll think about what every side thought the war was about and climate look in ~ the differences in between the Union and the Confederacy and compare your strengths and also weaknesses. Let’s gain started!
The American polite War stays the deadliest conflict in American background with a fatality toll the surpasses the combined total the American deaths in the first and second World Wars. In some ways it to be the very first modern conflict, through the usage of armored warships, railways, and also telegraphs. Yet in other means it was comparable to the Napoleonic Wars; men still fought and died shoulder come shoulder, part falling in battle and also others succumbing come dysentery.
The motivations compelling each side come wage together a devastating and also destructive battle were actually quite similar, at least in their own perspectives. Both the North and also the South declared to it is in fighting because that freedom. The North taken into consideration it a matter of preserving the Union and casting off the divisive and debilitating constraints of slavery. Because that the South, it was a fight for political rights and also asserting state sovereignty against an overbearing commonwealth government.
The causes of the Civil war were complex and numerous however ultimately stemmed from the question of slavery. Slavery had constantly been a allude of contention in the joined States, however the rapid expansion of the united state in the very first half the the 19th century offered to heighten this issue. Brand-new territories increased the concern of how they would function, whether as totally free or servant states. The Southern says saw the incorporation of free states together a threat, and also by 1858, the cost-free states surcharge the slave claims 17-15. The 1860 choice of Abraham Lincoln in November showed to be the final straw for the southerly states. Southern Carolina to be the an initial of eleven Southern claims to secede indigenous the Union. Lincoln sought to avoid equipped conflict however refused to surrender federal forts to the Confederates. Instead, Lincoln decided to send support and supplies to Fort Sumter in Charleston Harbor. Supply ships to be turned away and tensions grew surrounding the fort, causing Confederate president Jefferson Davis making a decision come strike against the fort. Top top April 12, 1861, Confederate guns fired the an initial shots the the American civil War.
From the outset, the North took pleasure in a clear benefit in industrial output. End 80% of the prewar unified States’ sector was concentrated in the northern states. The North to be able to produce its own weapons, and also over the course of the war, produced over two million rifles, if the South often had to depend on imports and captured weapons. This Northern benefit was the product of irreversible trends towards urbanization, education, and also immigration. Prior to the war, the South had made significant strides front in investing in industry and infrastructure, yet still lagged much behind the phibìc on the night of the polite War.
From 1800-1860, the percent of employees in agriculture fell considerably in the north while they continued to be steady in the South. Around 25% of americans in north states stayed in towns or cities contrasted to around 10% the Southerners. A huge influx that German and Irish immigrants flocked come the United says in the 18th and also 19th centuries, and the overwhelming bulk settled in the North.
The southern was a primarily farming economy centered approximately the manufacturing of life materials, an especially cotton. Through the use of slaves, the labor burden largely dropped on black color shoulders if the rewards fell into a small variety of white hands. The annual cotton yield doubled each decade of the early on 19th century and prices soared in the 1850s. Quite than invest earnings in industry and infrastructure, affluent Southerners instead bought an ext slaves and much more land. As well as the moral considerations, the booming Southern economic situation was constructed upon shaky foundations. More than 95% of southern output was for export, 70% overseas and also 20% was sent out to the northern states.
Now, the phibìc technically held much more advantages in terms of men, munitions, and also ships. Such a mismatch in resources would suggest simple victory because that the Union, but the reality showed to be anything but. Top top paper, the southern stood certain no chance of beating the North, but wars space not dealt with on ledgers and also spreadsheets. Together the American transformation had shown nearly a century before and the Vietnam battle would display a century later, substantial advantages in military strength nothing always an outcome in victory. Over there were number of equalizing components which prevent the phibìc from fully exploiting its product advantages.
The very first was the corresponding war aims of the North and also the South. The Union had actually to achieve total victory over the Confederacy, while the South organized confidence in your strictly defensive position. There to be reluctance that the north to fully commit to an all-out war, which might be seen in the early stage strategy to force the southern to come to terms. The Anaconda Plan was conceived by the veteran commander Winfield Scott to bring the south to a surrender there is no an overfill of bloodshed. The setup involved a naval blockade and the record of an essential points ~ above the Mississippi to choke off southerly exports. It was strategically sound, and the North kept a blockade because that the term of the war, however not enough to accomplish the public requirements for decisive action.
In 1860, the united States army had around 16,000 troops, mainly posted on the frontiers. Through a disproportionate price of trained policemans siding with the South, the shortage the trained leaders brought about politically-connected but inexperienced guys senioring command posts. The vast majority of the guys who dealt with the battle had little to no military experience. Just prior to the Battle that Bull Run top top July 21, 1861, the an initial major engagement that the war, general Irvin McDowell expressed worry his guys weren’t ready to fight. Lincoln, under an excellent political pressure, urged McDowell onward:
“You are eco-friendly it is true; but they are green also; girlfriend are environment-friendly alike.”
Lincoln’s position was understandable however his general’s warning proved to it is in correct. The Union battle plan fell apart as soon as the guys weren’t able to carry it out. The south won the quite shambolic battle but couldn’t totally capitalize ~ above it. This would certainly be a recurring trouble for the South; Robert E. Lee would regularly lament his army’s i can not qualify to decisively ruin the Union militaries he defeated. Lee’s strategy hinged on inflicting a damaging defeat on the phibìc to force them come terms. The South can not weather the same losses the North might withstand.
In regards to manpower, the North had actually a lot larger populace to draw from and also could change losses more readily than the South. Also so, there to be still some complications because that the Union when it pertained to recruitment. Those who volunteered for service with the Union in 1861 enlisted for simply 90 days. Once it became clear the battle wasn’t going to be practically as short as initially thought, much longer enlistment periods and also conscription laws were introduced. Dislike by the exemption which enabled wealthier northern males to to buy their means out of company with a $300 payment, draft riots damaged out in brand-new York in July that 1863. The slogan the the rioters was the it to be “a wealthy man’s war yet a bad man’s fight.”
The South had to impose much more drastic steps to to fill the ranks; a collection of significantly stringent conscription legislations were passed native 1862-1864. Favor the North, the rich were excused from serving in the military, as well as those through holdings the 20 or much more slaves. Unequal the North, the southern didn’t have the luxury of honoring enlistment periods. When the Confederate military got a uniform top top a recruit, there to be no way out. As a result, desertion became a serious difficulty for the Confederacy. Official figures give a variety of 103,000, however the true full might have actually been much higher.
The discrepancy in resources between the North and also the southern was likewise present in ~ sea. The South basically had to muster a makeshift navy from scratch and also had no method of break the north blockade. Come close the gap, the south made use of unconventional tools such together mines and very early submarine prototype. The latter machine did regulate to sink a Union ship but at the cost of the crew. The Confederacy at some point succumbed to the linked effects that the marine blockade and also territorial and also battlefield losses. The Union victory had actually not come easily and was by no way as unpreventable as the material benefits might have actually suggested. Abraham Lincoln additionally had to navigate a daunting political and also diplomatic environment in order to keep the Union.
All right, come wrap things up, let’s go over a pair of testimonial questions.
1. Which of the complying with was a an essential vulnerability of the southern economy?An export-focused economyPrice-gougingLabor shortagesHigh taxes
The correct answer is A! The focus on exporting raw products meant a marine blockade would seriously disrupt the flow of items and ability to sustain a war effort.
See more: What Do Budgies Eat In The Wild ? What Do Budgies Eat
2. I m sorry of the complying with did the north lack?Industrial capitalShipsTrained officersUniforms
The correct answer is C! The shortage that trained officers brought about the appointment of politically-connected yet inexperienced officers in an elderly positions.