‘Think outside the box’ is one of the biggest creativity cliches. The basic idea is that to be an imaginative you need to challenge your very own assumptions and look at things from a new angle. You require to break out of typical thinking and take off the blinkers created by previous experience.

You are watching: How to connect 9 dots with 4 straight lines

But is the really how creativity happens? and also will finding out to ‘think outside the box’ assist you become an ext creative?

The phrase is generally held to have originated through the standard ‘nine-dot’ imagination puzzle. If friend haven’t viewed this problem before, try to settle it before scrolling down and also reading the rest – you’ll gain a lot much more out the this article.

Get a pen and some record and copy the nine dots arranged in a square below. To fix the problem, you need to sign up with all ripe dots by illustration no much more than 4 straight lines. The directly lines should be consistent – i.e. You must not lift your pen native the file once you start drawing. Don’t read any further until you’ve make the efforts to fix the problem.


How walk you get on? If you regulated to settle it, offer yourself a beat on the earlier and read on. If you’re no there yet, here’s a proviso to aid you. If you’re like many people, friend will have tried to solve the trouble by keeping your lines within the ‘box’ developed by the dots. However if girlfriend look in ~ the instructions, over there is no necessity to carry out this. Therefore have another go at resolving the problem, enabling yourself to attract outside the box. Again, don’t read any type of further till you’ve either addressed it or offered up.

OK if you’ve either fixed it or had enough, click here to see two of the usual solutions.

What did you make of that? might you fix the trouble the an initial time? Did it make any kind of difference when I claimed you could go outside the box?

The typical Explanation

The usual method of presenting this difficulty is because that a creativity trainer come only give the an initial set of instructions – i.e. Without discussing the fact that you enable to go exterior the box. And almost everybody (including me, when I an initial saw it) totally fails to settle the problem. Yet most creative thinking trainers don’t bother v the 2nd stage – they just reveal the systems to actors of astonishment and protest from the audience: “that’s no fair! girlfriend didn’t tell united state we can go exterior the box!” come which the trainer typically responds “Aha! yet I didn’t tell you you couldn’t go external the box!”.

The trainer then trots the end the typical explanation that the puzzle: we can’t settle the difficulty as lengthy as we room thinking ‘inside the box’ created by ours assumptions. When we begin to think ‘outside the box’ we open up up many more possibilities and also it becomes easy to deal with the problem. This is true in therefore many areas of life – ours education, previous experience and also habitual thinking patterns save us trapped in limiting assumptions. That takes a real initiative to challenge the assumptions and think outside the box. Most of united state are really poor in ~ doing this and also have to work tough at the – unlike an imaginative geniuses to who this type of reasoning comes naturally.

In situation you think I’m having a go at imagination trainers I’ll confess the a couple of years ago, top top a pair of occasions, ns was that trainer. Never again.

Challenging an imaginative Convention

The trouble with the usual means of presenting the nine-dot trouble is that it consists of (ahem) an unexamined assumption. I.e. The all we need to do is tell world they deserve to go external the box and they will find it easy to resolve the problem. Yet most of the time human being are not given the possibility to discover out – they room simply given the solution and also told that the trouble was their limited thinking. They room usually so astonished to find that lock are enabled to draw outside package that they readily accept this explanation.

A few researchers have actually been sceptical and also curious sufficient to test this assumption. In creativity – beyond the myth of Genius Robert Weisberg explains two experiment in which civilization were told that the only means to settle the difficulty was to attract lines exterior the square. Contrary to the ‘outside the box’ institution of thought, this did no make difficulty easy to solve. In fact, only 20-25% of subjects were able to settle the problem, even though all of them enabled themselves to draw outside the box. And also even the ones who did settle the difficulty took a lengthy time to execute so, and also used trial and error, making numerous different drawings, fairly than any kind of special kind of ‘creative thinking’.

Researchers go on to display that the success rate could be enhanced by giving subjects front training in solving easier line-and-dot problems, and likewise by offering them “detailed strategy instructions” around how to fix the problem:

Lung and also Dominowski’s strategy instructions add to dot-to-dot.training assisted in solution the the nine-dot problem, yet still only a little much more than fifty percent of the subjects fixed the problem, and also they walk so not smoothly in a sudden burst that insight, however only ~ a variety of tries. This study provides specifically graphic evidence that insightful behaviour, contradictory to the Gestalt view, is the result of expertise.

See more: What Is A Substitute For Ground Cloves, Substitute For Ground Clove

Robert Weisberg, The legend of Genius

So the study evidence suggests that thinking external the box falls short to produce the expected an imaginative solution. And also far from gift a hindrance, previous experience and training have the right to actually be the an essential to an imaginative problem-solving.

What perform You Think?

If the trouble was new to you, might you settle it simply by following the initial instructions?

Did it make any difference when you to be told you could go external the box?

Is ‘thinking exterior the box’ a useful means to technique creativity or go it worthy its standing as the most despised piece of business jargon? Or is it simply that, as Brian likes to say, there is no box?