It’s been 55 years due to the fact that Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer an initial premiered top top NBC, and also watching the lovely TV unique is tho a Christmastime legacy for numerous families. 

You couldn’t ask for a more inspiring gang of outsiders 보다 Rudolph, wannabe dentist/elf Hermey, and everyone’s favourite prospector, Yukon Cornelius. After being cast out by their corresponding tribes, the trio turns to each other for companionship. 

During their travels with the phibìc Pole, they accidentally land on the Island that Misfit Toys, wherein those that are broken or undesirable go to live until they can discover a kid who will love them.

You are watching: Island of misfit toys what was wrong with the doll

Residents incorporate a jack-in-the-box called Charlie, a spotted elephant, a choo-choo train through square wheel on the caboose, a water pistol the shoots jelly, a bird the doesn’t fly, a cowboy who rides one ostrich, and also a boat that can’t remain afloat. 


One question that has plagued the stop motion animation classic because that years is why the doll, recognized as Dolly because that Sue to some, is ~ above the island. She never ever reveals what’s "wrong" v her, and nothing is physical off around her appearance. That took till 2005 because that fans to ultimately get one answer.

We first see Dolly because that Sue — "the sort that will also say 'How perform you do?'" — throughout "The most Wonderful day of the Year," which introduces the audience to the island’s lonely, yet confident inhabitants.

Though Dolly shows up joyful transparent the song, producer Arthur Rankin Jr. Revealed in an interview with the save of American television that she ended up ~ above the island due to depression and also low self-esteem. Yikes, that’s heavy.


"I constantly say, well, she has psychiatric problems. She to be under the care of one analyst," Arthur admitted. He elaborated on that suggest in a 2007 chat v NPR’s "Wait Wait… Don’t tell Me," stating the Dolly feeling unloved after being exit by her owner (who to be presumably Sue).

Dolly’s "issues" were very first hinted at on the Dolly for Sue Stuffins marketed by CVS in 1998. A tags attached to she body read: "I’m a tiny rag doll who just wants a friend. I think that will help my broken heart mend."

Arthur also revealed the the mystery surrounding Dolly’s visibility on the island stems from the fact that she was a last-minute addition to the broadcast. The producers felt they essential a misfit toy that young girls might relate come (remember, it to be a different time ago then).

See more: What Is The Lewis Dot Structure For Hcn, Hcn Lewis Structure & Molecular Geometry

As the special underwent revisions over the years, Dolly got more screen time and lines, do her lack of a physics defect an ext apparent. 


Two years prior to his death, Arthur to be asked about what makes Rudolph timeless. "I yes, really don’t have response to that," that confessed. "I think since it was the an initial special of its kind… ns think that, in looking for something to watch because that Christmas, parents put their children in prior of the television.

"And as the audience grew, so did the kids that watched it," he added. "They flourished up to end up being mothers. And also they grew up to become grandmothers! and they additionally put their children and grandchildren in front of the television set… To countless people, Rudolph method Christmas."