Pinocchio and Striving come Become

Part 1 of the collection How to be yourself, with assist from Disney/Pixar (Thinking around Identity and the inside Voice)

“Be yourself!” This advice is often given, and it seems choose it ought to be the easiest advice possible to follow. If who told me, “Be the CEO the a company,” that would take some work. If ns was told, “Be a gold-medal-winning Olympic weightlifter,” that would certainly be also harder. And also if the advice to be “Be a five-dimensional room turtle,” climate my puzzlement would just be outweighed by the impossibility of the task.

You are watching: Pinocchio i want to be a real boy

But I have actually already completed being me. … Or have I?


If I must be called to it is in myself, this means that there is a method in i beg your pardon I deserve to fail at the task. And if this is the case, then we deserve to ask more how I could fail or what it would look like to succeed. That is, us would require to address the object of identity.

When ns speak of mine identity, i am speaking of the thing or things that define me. That am ns fundamentally? This matters, since it shapes what ns do. If Maggie sees it s her as mainly a CEO (that is, in regards to her job), climate she will certainly prioritize her work over other obligations. If everyone expects Max to be a Christian, however he watch his identification as being a Marxist, then he might decide to go versus the desire of his community, also if it prices him. How I view my identity shapes my life.

There is a many that can be said around identity, but in this collection I’m walking to emphasis on a details aspect of the issue: perform I discover out that I am by looking within myself or through looking come something exterior of me? that is, do I follow my inner voice or do I heed an outside call?


In order come think about these questions, I’m walking to revolve to the experts. Disney and Pixar have actually been experimenting the worry of identity in your animated movies for years, therefore I will certainly use several of these together examples. My goal is to make explicit the ideas that lie behind the stories and contrast your differing visions that what it means to it is in me.

In this an initial post i will start by looking at Disney’s 2nd animated feature, Pinocchio. I intend I should concern a spoiler alert, due to the fact that I will be pointing out the details of the plot. However really, you’ve had 80 year to clock this movie, so that is your own fault if you haven’t. (And i guess the title of this post already gave away the ending, so whoops.)

Pinocchio is a high-point amongst Disney’s hand-drawn man features. I did not totally appreciate it till I saw a documentary ~ above the movie a couple of years ago, but the fist to information in the drawings is amazing. Together a story, top top the various other hand, Pinocchio is quite strange: a wood boy, counseled through a cricket, is repetitively seduced by temptation and also eventually swallowed through a whale. Oh, and also there is the whole nose-elongation-in-response-to-untruths thing. Additionally, being at an early stage Disney—the Disney the shot Bambi’s mother and also caged Dumbo’s—the movie does not shy far from nightmare-inducing imagery, an especially the pilgrimage to satisfied Island and also the coachman that brings the boys there (and takes them away together donkeys).

The movie starts v the tune that became Disney’s theme: “When You great Upon a Star.” This tune is the elevation of self-focused wonder thinking, declaring that as soon as you execute the titular action, “anything your heart desire will pertained to you” and also that “if her heart is in her dream, no inquiry is too extreme.”


Jiminy Cricket even starts the movie through citing the following story as proof that desires do come true. V a start like this, the viewer is primed because that an inward-focused movie urging united state to it is in ourselves by adhering to our dreams. … but this is not what happens.

Instead, Pinocchio looks exterior in two ways. First, while identification is main to the story, it focuses not on what Pinocchio is currently, but on what that is striving to become. He starts off a continual wooden puppet, but Geppetto the toymaker wishes that he would certainly be a genuine boy. The Blue Fairy comes and also grants Geppetto’s great in part, bringing Pinocchio to life. He is no made a boy appropriate away, however, i beg your pardon sets increase the arc the the story: becoming a actual boy is Pinocchio’s goal. The identity that cd driver him, then, is not what the is yet what he is striving come be. The does not say, “I to be a puppet, for this reason I will be content with that and also do puppetish things,” yet he does what he does in bespeak to accomplish his goal of boyhood.

Second, the method he will reach his score is also looking outward. He is not going to listen to his inside voice, yet he will become a genuine boy by learning to do what is right. He will not monitor his heart, yet he will certainly let his conscience be his guide.

Now, one might object that occasionally the conscience is referred to as the within voice, so exactly how is following his conscience spring outward? on the one hand, Pinocchio’s conscience is accurate external. Jiminy Cricket theatre this role, being officially dubbed Pinocchio’s conscience by the Blue Fairy.


And an ext than this, even when the conscience is properly internal to the mind, its function as envisioned in Pinocchio is quiet to suggest me to something outside myself. Under any type of conception the the conscience, it is something separate from my desire (what i want) and my will certainly (what i do). It have the right to oppose both, or together Jiminy Cricket says, “A conscience is the still, small voice that world won’t hear to.” It speak me no what I want or what ns do, however what ns should do.

Separating conscience from mine desires and also will could still be compatible v seeing it together pointing come something internal to me. One conception the the conscience is to check out it as the an individual standards i have embraced for myself.


But this is not Pinocchio‘s vision of the conscience. The sees the conscience as pointing me exterior myself come the objective requirements of morality. As the Blue Fairy defines Jiminy Cricket’s role, he is to it is in “lord high keeper of the understanding of right and wrong, counselor in moment of temptation, and guide follow me the straight and narrow path.” In order to become a genuine boy, Pinocchio must have very first withstood the temptations appealing to his desires and also shown instead that the is “brave, truthful, and unselfish.”

So, given that Pinocchio’s conscience is both speaking and pointing externally, if we room to discuss an inside voice in the context of the movie, what would certainly it be? Pinocchio is therefore innocent and naïve that he doesn’t really have actually much of an inner life. This is component of the story, because it is dramatizing both his conscience and also his temptations as characters external to him. More than likely the closest he involves expressing his inner thoughts is when he’s on satisfied Island and also declares that “being bad’s a many fun.” The story of pleasure Island, where boys have the right to fight, smoke, and play pool, clearly paints the impulses to execute these things as bad. Together the evil coachman states, “Give a poor boy enough rope, and also he’ll quickly make a jackass that himself.” Pinocchio and the other boys must not be listening come the within voice that desire, yet they should follow what is best instead.

Pinocchio at some point learns his lesson, and also when Geppetto is swallowed by the whale Monstro, the goes in search of him. That rescues the from the whale, consisting of staying with Geppetto after being told to leaving him behind and save himself. The rescue is successful, yet Pinocchio dies in the process. However, because that his bravery and also unselfishness, the Blue Fairy bring him back to life, this time no longer as a puppet. As Pinocchio realizes the he has lastly reached his goal, he declares, “I’m a actual boy!”

When it involves identity, then, Pinocchio sets increase the following order: 1) Don’t action on what I find within myself. 2) Instead, execute what is right, including serving others. 3) By concentrating on others and also what is right, I will be rewarded by coming to be the human I desire to be, the identity I am striving for.

This is one attractive account the identity. That fits v an account of virtuous living as the goal of life, such as the one offered by Aristotle. Because that him, the type of life we want to have is one where we have actually virtue and are displaying it. None of us start off virtuous by nature, so we should work in ~ obtaining virtue with the continuous practice of virtuous actions. Eventually our actions will not be triggered by one external collection of rule we room following, but they will circulation from a state in ~ us. We will have end up being the virtuous human being we to be striving to be.

Similarly, indigenous a Christian view I start off together a sinful person, one whose love is inclined toward selfishness rather than towards what is right. So, ns shouldn’t just do what my love says, however I should consciously effort to conform my life to God’s standards. I will certainly still it is in a sinner transparent my life, one who does not always live up to the standards of righteousness, but God has actually promised to renew my love in the following life and also give me the righteousness i seek. Even now, then, my identification is discovered in what I will certainly be, no what ns am. I am guided by this vision of my brand-new self.

Of course, there is additionally a method that the article of Pinocchio different from the Biblical view: it is fundamentally moralistic. Best from the start of his life, the Blue Fairy renders it clear that Pinocchio need to earn his boyhood by being good. “To make Geppetto’s wish come true will certainly be entirely up come you. … Prove yourself brave, truthful, and unselfish, and someday you will certainly be a actual boy.” Later, ~ Pinocchio pursues wealth and also fame instead of goodness, finishing up in a cage together a result, the Blue Fairy returns. She help him but says it is the last time she deserve to do so. She likewise accompanies her assist with a trite moralism: “I’ll pardon you this once, but remember, a boy who won’t be good might just also be make of wood.”

Now, I acknowledge that as soon as it concerns children’s stories there is a certain amount of leveling that should occur, and also encouraging kids to execute the best thing is not bad. It is likewise the case that in the bible what we do is no irrelevant come our result in life. However, as someone that is relying top top the grace of God—on the Bible’s central promise that it is God who saves us from the biggest repercussion of ours wrongdoing, not we who conserve ourselves—I find it disappointing to have the supernatural figure be a nag rather than a comforter.

And setting aside this issue, one can wonder about another aspect of Pinocchio‘s message. What walk it typical to look to an external, target morality, and also how does together a morality exist? This is a great question come ask and one that has received countless answers. One could, for example appeal come a utilitarian or Kantian explanation of morality, return I find each of this problematic. I will not attend to this question more now, but I do setup to address it more in a future short article in this series.

In the following post, however, ns am going to look at the other finish of the spectrum native Pinocchio when it comes to thinking about identity and the within voice. Pinocchio might listen come Jiminy Cricket, however when Moana sails the seas she will learn to turn inward.

See more: Dismissal For Want Of Prosecution In Divorce, Dismissing A Divorce In Illinois

Share this write-up or sign up because that future posts:


Pinocchio. Walt Disney computer animation Studios, 1940.

How to it is in yourself, with help from Disney/Pixar (Thinking about Identity and also the within Voice)

Categories just how to it is in yourself, with help from Disney/Pixar (Thinking around Identity and the inner Voice) tags Conscience, Disney, Identity, within Voice, Pinocchio, Striving article navigation