The last trailer for wonderful Beasts: The crimes of Grindelwald reduce a ssssshocking bombshell around the beginnings of Nagini, however that wasn’t the only major Harry Potter connection reflected in it. When again Jude Law’s Dumbledore was watched gazing right into the famed Mirror of Erised, the one that confirmed so necessary in The Sorcerer’s Stone. And what us know around his past and also how that magical artifact works reveals one major truth: no issue how directly (or not) the franchise addresses Dumbledore’s sexuality, the won’t change the means we think about the character.

You are watching: What dumbledore sees in the mirror of erised


Almost nothing is known around the origins of the winter of Erised, not who made it, whereby it came from, or how it even finished up in ~ Hogwarts. It satellite in the Room of necessity for almost a hundreds years before Dumbledore amendment it right into a hiding place and also a test for the pure of heart, which proved an essential to Harry maintaining the Sorcerer’s rock from Professor Quirrell and also Voldemort.

What is known is what that does. At the peak of the high mirror, in the ornate gold frame, lies an engraving that reads “erised stra ehru oyt ube cafru oyt ~ above wohsi.” Backwards that says, “I show not her face but your heart’s desire.” as soon as Harry looked in it he saw his parents, because he want a family an ext than anything, and also Ron observed himself as Head Boy and Quidditch Cup captain and also champion, since he yearned to escape his brothers’ shadows.


When Harry returned for a third straight night to stare into it he was greeted by a waiting Dumbledore, who explained exactly exactly how it works. “It mirrors us nothing an ext or less than the deepest, many desperate desires of our hearts.” not everyone would want their deepest, many desperate desires common with the world, therefore it’s a great thing the visions are personal to the gazer, concealed from anyone else that looks. Yet that tantalizing vision is why it deserve to be for this reason dangerous, as Dumbledore explained.

“However, this mirror will give us neither knowledge or truth. Men have actually wasted away before it, entranced by what they have actually seen, or been moved mad, not learning if what it shows is actual or even possible.”

On Pottermore, J.K. Rowling has written around the dangers further: “The advice come ‘hold ~ above to your dreams’ is all well and good, yet there come a suggest when holding on to your dreams becomes unhelpful and also even unhealthy. Dumbledore knows the life have the right to pass you by when you room clinging on to a wish that can never it is in – or ought never ever to it is in – fulfilled.” Just due to the fact that you watch something doesn’t median you can ever before have it, and maybe much more importantly, that you ever before should.

That wisdom Dumbledore common with Harry came 50 year after the occasions of The crime of Grindelwald though, and the young Dumbledore in the trailers has actually been checked out staring right into the winter of Erised lot of times. It’s likely he just learned just how dangerous it can be from experience. And also because we know what he sees, we know what his very own deepest, darkest desire is–his closest friend and the young guy with who he once plotted to preeminence the world: Gellert Grindelwald, both as a young man and as the Dark Wizard he became.


The Deathly Hallows told the story about the tumultuous, whirlwind relationship between the 2 young, powerful wizards, which brought about the death of Ariana Dumbledore. Your friendship was already complex and tragic prior to J.K. Rowling revealed in 2007 that Dumbledore was in love v Grindelwald.

“Dumbledore fell in love with Grindelwald, and that added to his horror when Grindelwald proved himself to be what he was. To an extent, perform we to speak it excused Dumbledore a little more because fallout’s in love can blind united state to one extent, yet he met someone as brilliant as he was and, rather prefer Bellatrix, the was very drawn to this excellent person and also horribly, horrible let down by him.”

This all seems so obvious. Dumbledore watch Grindelwald, both together a young man and the older Dark Wizard, in the winter of Erised due to the fact that he never stopped being in love v him and always hoped they could be together, i beg your pardon is why he was reluctant come fight him for years (he won’t confront him until 1945). Unfortunately, us can’t i think the franchise will ever before directly and explicitly say any type of of this. Manager David Yates has actually said The crime of Grindelwald won’t resolve Dumbledore’s sexuality explicitly, and while us hope that’s only since it will occur in the next three prequels, it’s difficult to provide the full advantage of the doubt come a studio that proceeds to employ Johnny Depp, who credibly accused of residential abuse.

But whether Dumbledore ever reveals come anyone what–or fairly who–he look at in the Mirror and also why, and also whether the movies ever address the real reason the sees Grindelwald, that won’t adjust how we think that the character. We’ll be extremely disappointed and also disgusted if this facility personal connection is just hinted in ~ in the subtext, however we understand who Dumbledore really is. He’s a gay man who to be asked to fight the only human he ever before loved to conserve the world. That’s a beautiful, haunting story that can’t be taken away from united state now.

See more: Where Does The Phrase Clean As A Whistle Come From, Clean As A Whistle


What execute you think the mirror of Erised method for the rest of the Fantastic Beasts franchise? Tell united state in the comments ar below.